Rent Guarantee Insurance: Is It Worth It?

Ross McColl
11 min read
Jul 24, 2024
Updated: Jul 24, 2024

Rent guarantee insurance can provide peace of mind for landlords, ensuring they receive rental income even if tenants default. But is it truly worth it?

This blog post will discuss rent guarantee insurance. The sentence will explain what rent guarantee insurance is and how it works. Also covered will be the advantages and possible disadvantages of rent guarantee insurance. This information will help you make a well-informed decision.

What is Rent Guarantee Insurance?

Rent guarantee insurance is a policy that covers landlords against the loss of rental income because of tenant default. It typically includes legal expenses and sometimes covers eviction costs. This insurance is popular with landlords who want to protect their rental income from tenant behaviour and economic changes.

How Rent Guarantee Insurance Works

Policy Coverage: The policy compensates for unpaid rent during the term of the tenancy agreement. This ensures that landlords can maintain a steady income stream even if their tenants fail to pay rent.

Claim Process: Landlords must often wait for a specified period (e.g., one month) after the rent is due before making a claim. Landlords should remind tenants to pay rent.

They should also keep records of all communication. Additionally, landlords should document their efforts to resolve any issues. After the waiting period, landlords can submit a claim to the insurance company with the required documentation.

Legal Support: Rent guarantee insurance often includes legal assistance for eviction processes. If a tenant doesn't pay rent, the insurance company may help with the costs of evicting them, like court fees and lawyer expenses. Landlords can benefit from legal support when they need help with the eviction process.

Eligibility Criteria

Tenant Background Checks: Policies generally require tenants to pass a credit check. This is to ensure that tenants have a history of paying their bills on time and are less likely to default on rent. Some insurance companies may also require additional checks, such as employment verification and references from previous landlords.

Documentation: Landlords must provide proof of rental arrears and tenancy agreements. This includes a signed lease agreement, bank statements with missed payments, and any messages with the tenant about unpaid rent. Proper documentation is crucial to support a claim and ensure a smooth and timely payout from the insurance company.

Cost of Rent Guarantee Insurance

Premiums: Typically calculated as a percentage of the annual rental income. Premium costs can change based on where the property is, the tenant's credit, and how much coverage the landlord picks. Landlords typically pay 3% to 6% of their yearly rental income for rent guarantee insurance.

Additional Costs: May include administrative fees or higher premiums for high-risk tenants. Some insurance companies may charge extra fees for processing claims. They may also charge for offering additional services like property inspections or tenant mediation. Landlords should carefully read their policy to know all possible costs.

Landlord explaining to the client

Benefits of Rent Guarantee Insurance

Financial Security

Stable Income: Guarantees rental income even if tenants default. This financial security helps landlords plan their finances more effectively. It ensures they can cover expenses such as mortgage payments, property maintenance, and taxes promptly.

Legal Expenses Covered: Helps cover the cost of legal proceedings for eviction. Legal costs can quickly add up, especially if the eviction process is prolonged or contested by the tenant. Rent guarantee insurance covers expenses, easing financial burden for landlords. This allows them to focus on managing properties instead of worrying about legal fees.

Peace of Mind

Less Stress: Landlords are protected against financial loss, reducing stress. Landlords can feel at ease with guaranteed rental income, freeing them up to handle other property management duties.

Assured Payments: Timely compensation ensures financial stability. Rent guarantee insurance helps landlords receive payment quickly from the insurance company. This reduces the risk of financial problems and ensures that landlords can pay their bills on time.

Tenant Screening

Quality Tenants: Insurers often require thorough background checks, leading to better tenant quality. This can lead to less problems with rent payments and property damage, which saves landlords time and money in the end.

Reduced Risk: Fewer chances of renting to tenants who may default. Rent guarantee insurance helps landlords by making sure tenants pass credit checks and screenings. This reduces the chances of tenants not paying rent. This insurance helps landlords avoid risky tenants.

Drawbacks of Rent Guarantee Insurance


Premium Expenses: Adds to the overall cost of property management. Rent guarantee insurance helps landlords financially, but it comes with additional costs. These costs are known as premiums. Landlords need to factor these premiums into their budgets.

Deductibles: Some policies may have deductibles that policyholders need to pay before settling claims. Landlords may have to pay some unpaid rent or legal expenses themselves before insurance helps.


Eligibility Criteria: Stringent tenant screening requirements. While thorough screenings can lead to higher-quality tenants, they can also limit the pool of potential tenants. Some renters may not meet insurance company requirements, making it harder for landlords to find new tenants quickly.

Exclusions: Certain circumstances (e.g., tenant disputes) might not be covered. Rent guarantee insurance policies often have exclusions that landlords need to be aware of. For example, some policies may not cover rental income loss due to tenant disputes, natural disasters, or other specific events.

Claim Process

Waiting Period: Often a delay before claims can be made. Waiting for rent can cause money problems for landlords who need it to pay their bills.

Documentation: Extensive paperwork required to process claims. Gathering and submitting the necessary documentation can be time-consuming and may require landlords to keep meticulous records of all rental transactions and communications with tenants.

Assessing Coverage

How to Choose the Right Rent Guarantee Insurance

Assessing Coverage

Comprehensive Policies: Look for policies covering both rent arrears and legal expenses. Comprehensive coverage protects landlords against multiple risks, giving them a greater sense of security.

Understand the exclusions and the maximum payout limits. Carefully reviewing the policy details can help landlords avoid unexpected surprises and ensure they have the coverage they need.

Comparing Premiums

Shop Around: Compare quotes from different insurers to find the best deal. Taking the time to compare multiple policies can help landlords find the most cost-effective option that meets their needs.

Discounts: Check if insurers offer discounts for multiple properties or long-term policies. Some insurance companies give discounts to landlords who have multiple properties or long-term policies. These discounts can help reduce the overall costs for landlords.

Reading Reviews

Customer Feedback: Read reviews to gauge the reliability of the insurer. You can learn about an insurance company's reputation and services by reading reviews and testimonials from other landlords. This information can give you insight into the experiences of others with the company.

It is important to consider the opinions of others when choosing an insurance provider. Reviews and testimonials can provide valuable information to help you make an informed decision.

Claim Settlements: Check the insurer’s reputation for settling claims efficiently. A key factor in choosing an insurance provider is their track record for processing and paying out claims promptly and fairly.


Rent guarantee insurance can be a valuable safety net for landlords, offering financial protection and peace of mind. However, it's essential to weigh the costs and benefits, understand the policy details, and choose a reputable insurer. By carefully assessing coverage options, comparing premiums, and reading customer reviews, landlords can find a rent guarantee insurance policy that meets their needs and provides the security they desire. If you are a landlord looking to safeguard your rental income, rent guarantee insurance is worth considering. Additionally, landlords should consider having landlord insurance to cover potential property damage and liability claims, offering a more comprehensive protection strategy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is rent guarantee insurance?

Rent guarantee insurance is a policy that ensures landlords receive payment even if tenants fail to pay. This insurance covers lost rent and legal costs, providing financial protection against tenant default and helping landlords maintain a steady income stream.

How much does rent guarantee insurance cost?

The cost varies but is typically a percentage of the annual rental income, with additional administrative fees possible. Factors such as the location of the property, the tenant's creditworthiness, and the level of coverage chosen by the landlord can all influence the cost of premiums.

What does rent guarantee insurance cover?

It covers rental arrears and often legal expenses related to tenant eviction. Comprehensive policies may also include coverage for property damage caused by tenants or other specific risks outlined in the policy.

How do I make a claim on rent guarantee insurance?

Landlords need to show proof of late rent, the lease, and may have to wait before asking for the money. The claim process typically involves submitting documentation such as the signed lease agreement, bank statements showing missed payments, and any correspondence with the tenant. Once the waiting period is over, landlords can file a claim with the insurance company, which will review the documentation and process the payout.

Is rent guarantee insurance worth it?

For many landlords, the financial security and peace of mind it provides make rent guarantee insurance a worthwhile investment. By protecting against the risk of tenant default and covering legal expenses, rent guarantee insurance can help landlords manage their properties more effectively and reduce financial stress. However, it's important to carefully consider the costs, coverage options, and eligibility criteria to determine if it is the right choice for your specific situation.